Dette er listen over 18 sange indeholdt i albummet. Du kan klikke på en for at se de tilsvarende tekster og oversættelser.
Dette er en lille liste over sange oprettet af How It Should Have Ended, der kunne sunges under koncerten, inklusive navnet på albummet, hvorfra hver sang kom:
- He's a Spider-Man
- Where'd It Go? (Let It Go Parody) (Unreleased)
- What Does the Lex Say?
- Everything Is Batman (Parody)
- Don't You Forget About Bing Bong
- Legolas Anthem
- Camo Camo Camouflage
- Music Got Weird
- Yield to the Shield (Capt. America Parody)
- Prison Guest (Be Our Guest Parody)
- Bat Blood
- Nuthin' But an Alien
- Subscribe (The Misty Mountains Cold Parody) (Unreleased)
- Do You Hear the Wolverine? (Les Mis Parody) (Unreleased)
- The Tron Rap
- Lapidus Theme Song (Lost Parody)
- It's on Intro
- Could've Stopped Krall (Sabotage Parody)